User:Alexlin01/NH cognates/Phonology

All are tentative.

Reconstructed Phonologies by Language

edit

Proto-North Halmahera

edit
labial dental/alveolar palato-alveolar palatal velar glottal
nasal m n ɲ ŋ
stop voiceless p1, p2 t t͡ʃ ⟨c*⟩ k (ʔ)
voiced b d d͡ʒ ⟨*j⟩ ɟ? ⟨*ḋ?⟩ ɡ
fricative voiceless f s ɕ? ⟨*Z?⟩1
approximant central w j? ⟨*y?⟩
lateral l
flap/trill ɾ or r ⟨*r⟩

1 This is Voorhoeve's *S, but I personally tend toward a voiced phoneme.

Old West Makian

edit

Proto-Nuclear North Halmahera

edit

Proto-Galela Loloda

edit

Proto-Sahuic

edit

Proto-Ternate-Tidore

edit

Reflexes

edit

All are tentative and subject to significant revision.

Initial Position
PNH *m *p1 *p2 *b *f *w *n *t *d *s *l *L *r *c *j (d͡ʒ) *ḋ *Z *y? *k *g
› Old West Makian
›› West Makian
› PPNH *m *p1 *p2 *b *h *w *n *t *d *s *l *L *r *c *j *ḋ *Z *y? *k *g
›› PTT *m *f *p *b *h *w *n *t *d *s *l *L *r *c *j *ḋ *r *y? *k *g
››› Ternate m f p b h w n t d s l ? r ɲ c j h r y? ŋ k g ʔ
››› Tidore m f f b h w n t d s l l r ɲ c j y r y? ŋ k g y?
›› PNeNH *m *p1 *p2 *b *h *w *n *t *d *s *l *l *r *n *t *d *ḋ *Z *y? *k *g
››› PGL *m *p1 *p2 *b *h *w *n *t *d *s *l *l *r *n *t *d *ḋ *Z *y? *k *g 1
›››› Galela m p p b h w n t d s l l r n t d s y? ŋ k g ʔ1
›››› Loloda m w p b Ø Ø n t d s l l r n t d j j y? ŋ k g ???
›››› Proto-Tobelo2
››››› Tobelo Heleworuru
››››› Tobelo Boeng
››››› Tobelo Dodinga
›››› Pagu
›››› Modole
›››› Tabaru (Nyeku)

1 Lost phonemic status without having been lost phonetically.
2 Should not be too old of a stage; may even be able to call it "Old Tobelo" if any historical attestations exist.

Sequential Developments by Language

edit

Modole

edit
  1. Glottal-Stop Insertion Rule (in PNeNH)
  2. Loss of all glottal stops (Modole ali (to cry), Modole tii'iti (to have a cold, cough))
  3. *k → ʔ (fairly recent, even Ternate loans have ʔ in place of k)

Tabaru

edit
  1. *c → t
  2. *l → Ø (Tabaru caana (pants) from Malay celana)

Sahuic

edit
  1. *k → ʔ
  2. *p1 → w

Possible Proto-Phonemes

edit

*p1 vs. *p2

edit

The phoneme /*p1/ may have been [pʷ] and /*p2/ may have been [p]. Evidence for /*p1/ = [pʷ]:

Alternations between *p1 and *p2

edit

Note the alternations (with similar, if not identical, meanings) between the pair *'p1a.lus and *'p2a.lus and the pair *'p1o.kor and *'p2o.kor. Also, a number of languages have an irregular development of *'p1 to p or *'p2 to f/h/w.

  1. Consonant temporarily denoted /*Z/ (since I can only think of something like /ʐ/ or /ʂ/ that could give rise to these), with the consonant correspondences:
    • Galela /s/, Tobelo /h/, Tabaru /s/, Modole /h/; Loloda /d͡ʒ/, Pagu /l/, Sahu /r/; Ternate /r/, Tidore /r/, W. Makian /d/
    • PGL: /*Z/
      • Pre-Galela: merged with /*s/
      • Pre-Loloda: merged with /*ḋ/
        • Loloda: /d͡ʒ/
    • PSahuic: merged with /*r/
    • Pre-Tobelo: merged with /*s/
    • Pre-Tabaru: merged with /*s/
    • Pre-Pagu: merged with /*r/ or /*l/ (depending on whether Pagu /r/ descends from PNH or is a reintroduction after merging with /l/)
    • Pre-Modole: merged with /*s/
    • PTT: merged with /*r/
    • Old W. Makian: merged with /*d/?

*c (and *j)

edit

Consonant temporarily denoted /*c/ that develops into /t/ (Galela, Loloda, Tabaru, Tobelo, Pagu, Modole) and /c/ (Sahu, Ternate, Tidore), with W. Makian as yet uncertain.

May not be phonemic (see Kotynski's paper), and for now is phonetically indicated wherever possible. Initial-position reconstruction for nouns is almost entirely dependent on the Sahu reflex and for verbs can be adduced from how its N- prefixed form surfaces (with initial g indicating a glottal stop and initial ng indicating a plain vowel - as per both Hayami-Allen and Kotynski). Tobelo may also be helpful, but needs more investigation. Medially, Galela and Tabaru reflexes also presumably continue PNNH .

Specifically, initial glottal stops in Tabaru reflect both PNNH vowel-initials and ʔ-initials. A lack of initial ʔ in Tabaru is evidence of a lost consonant (PNH *h, *l, *w, and sometimes ). Galela appears to introduce a non-phonemic ʔ before every intial stressed vowel.

It is possible that *ʔ may have originally been /*q/. This could explain its *N- prefixed realization *g, if the process were *N- + *q and merged with *g while *q developed into a glottal stop. May also explain the errant realizations of *'ʔa.ŋe(r) ("three"), with surfacing as both a glottal stop and as k.

Sound Correspondences
Possible Reconstruction Gloss Galela Loloda Tobelo Tabaru Pagu Sahu/Waioli Ibu Ternate Tidore West Makian
*buLVŋ (PNH) (stative) white - - - - bubulang buḏo (S), budana (W) bulana budo bulo bulo
*poLi (PNH) to buy fodi foli poli
*jaLuk (PNNH) sagwire dalu daluku daluku caḏu (T), jadu'u (W)
*Lusuŋ (PNeNH) mortar lusu lusungu luhungu lusing
*p1aLus (PNNH) to respond palu walusu haluhu walusu walus waḏusu fadu falu
*gubaLi (PNNH) left side gubali gubali gubadi (B) gubali gubaḏi (S), gubadi (W) gubali gubadi
*hoLuk (PNNH) to not want, refuse holu holuku oluku oluku oluk oḏu'u (S), odu'u (W) hodu holu fono???
*iLiŋ (PNNH) voice ili ilingi ilingi ilingi iḏingi idi oli???
*Liŋan (PNNH) (intransitive) to travel by land; road (N-?) lingana lingana ḏingana Dodinga(?), linga linga
*Luit (PNNH) (transitive) to cut luiti luiti luiti ḏuiti
*Lutu (PNNH) (intransitive) to sink lutu lutu lutu dutu (W)
*maLi (PNNH) (stative) bitter mali mali mali mali mamaḏi madi mali
*seLuk (PNNH) (intransitive) to joke, kid, (stative) funny heluku seḏu'u sedu
*siLo (PNNH) resin, torch silo hilo silo silo siḏo sido
*suLok (PNNH) (transitive) to order, command sulo suloko huloko sudo sulo
*taiL (PNNH) (transitive) to try, attempt tai taili taili taiḏi

And so we have the following distribution

Sound Correspondences (initial/medial/final)
Possible Reconstruction Gloss Galela Loloda Tobelo Tabaru Pagu Modole Sahu/Waioli/Gamkonora Ibu Ternate Tidore West Makian
*l l/l/- l/l/l Ø/Ø/Ø Ø/Ø/Ø l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l
*r r/r/- r/r/r r/r/r r/r/r r/r/r l/l/l r/r/r ? l/l/l r/r/- r/r/- r/r/?
*L l/l/- l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l l/l/l ḏ,d,d/ḏ,d,d/ḏ,d,d ? d/d/- l/l/- l/l/?
  • but see also *moleun, *p2ilok, *p2olikur
  • While these may be conditioned instances of /l/ by neighboring /o/, /u/, or /a/, there are many terms (like *ŋolot, *p1ola, *laḋem, *lakem, *p2olotek), that suggest /l/ contrasts from this /L/.
  • Also, Fortgens, in his Tabaru Grammar, notes "Veel Tab. woorden hebben een l tegen die van het S.-W. een d." (pg. 323). Fortgens hadn't yet discovered the implosives in Sahu.
  • Interesting to note is how many of the above terms are likely borrowed from Austronesian.

Potential correspondences

edit
  1. Final (ignoring the echo) Paḏisua ʔ and Tala'i
  2. Occasional Northern (Tabaru, Tobelo, Galela, etc.) s and Ternate/Tidore/Sahu c when the more usual correspondence is t and c

Unexpecteds and Open Questions

edit

"Improper Retentions" in non-TT/Sahuic "inherited" vocabulary

edit

Note the comparanda where the Ternate term (in its present form) cannot be the direct donor of the Northern forms.

Ternate Tidore English Sahu Tobelo Tabaru Loloda Galela Pagu Modole
cala cala 1000 caana, saana caana calana cala
joou; coou lord, sultan; serve "jo'óng" joungu jo'oungu; co'oungu
juanga juanga large Ternatean canoe used to collect tribute "juángan" (juangana?) juangana juanga juangana juanga
raca to tear racanga
salawako shield hawako (B) sawa'unu salawakunu salawako salawakun hawa'unu
saya saya flower sasaya'a

Possible explanations include:

  1. Borrowings from Sahu, if we assume the Sahu terms to be inherited
  2. Borrowings from Pre-Ternate-Tidore (before the loss of finals in TT)
    • These loans would have reintroduced palatals to the Northern languages
    • This presumes that this Pre-TT period coincided with the period after which the native palatals had been lost in the Northern languages
    • If the kingdom of Jailolo actually had the influence that legend gives it, then this early Jailolo language (Old Jailolo, to distinguish from what Katarabumi might have written down?) might be the most likely candidate, possibly equivalent to PTT or a separate branch within TT

Notice also that (as yet) these all could be culture loans (even the numeral 1000).

Almost Reconstructible Terms

edit
  • *gani and *gaʔani ("louse")
    *gani (all but Tabaru)
    *gaʔani (Tabaru)
  • *roŋa and *romaŋ ("name")
    *roŋa (Ternate, Tidore, Galela, Tabaru, Modole - possibly borrowed into the last three)
    *romaŋ (Sahu, Gamkonora, Tobelo (B & H), Loloda, Pagu)
  • *suramo and *sauramo ("fog, mist")
    *suramo (Ternate, Tidore [soramo])
    *sauramo (Tobelo (H & B), Modole, Pagu, West Makian)
    sairamo (Sahu)

Tidore

edit

Intervocalic /k/ and its absence

edit
  • The NH cognate is Ternate by default and specified when not Ternate.

Interestingly, in van der Crab's glossary from the 1862, he lists many of these Tidore terms with an 'h' in place of a 'k' (laho). However, he write "lao" for Sahu la'o. I did though get the impression that this wordlist was not produced by him, but compiled from other sources. And, de Clercq (1890) writes simply "lau".

This list contains (I think) all the examples of k-elision in Tidore found in the data I have (Kamus Bahasa Tidore, etc.). But, the examples given for k-retention are only a small subset of the ones in the data. There appears to be no pattern; k is lost and retained in the same vocalic environments and k is lost and retained in core and non-core vocabulary (and morphemes).

Loss of /k/
Tidore NH Cognate* English
bii biki tail
doudou dodoku bridge
fayaa, foyaa foheka woman
fuu fuku to sell
gau gaku tall; high
hoo hoko seawards (directional)
hou hoku burnt, scorched
ia ika there, beyond, thither
lao lako eye
lau laku too much
mou moku to carry on the shoulders
moumou mokumoku (ocean) waves
naonao nako know, recognize
rui ruki to spin
tamao tamako axe
Retention of /k/
Tidore NH Cognate* English
ake ake water
aki aki tongue
bateko, boteko boteko upper arm
cako cako to strike; time; hour
haki haki to peel
maku- maku- reciprocalizing prefix
roka roka to pass
saki saki tasty
sako sako neck; stem, stalk
uku uku fire

Other considerations

edit

*N- prefixation

edit
  • *N- + *p1*b
  • *N- + *p2*b
  • *N- + *t*d
  • *N- + *c*j
  • *N- + *ḋ
  • *N- + *k*g
  • *N- + *g
  • *N- + *w
  • *N- + *h
  • *N- + *∅

Pre-Nasalization hypothesis

edit

Purely conjectural: voiced stops may have been originally prenasalized. Evidence:

  • N- prefixation (be it actually ŋ- prefixation or otherwise): (for example) *N + *p = *Np*ᵐbb (in reflexes) works a little more nicely than without the prenasalization hypothesis. Additionally, *N + = *Nʔ may plausibly have become *g (but this is far from clear phonetically).
  • Supports *tofʔaŋe*topʔaŋe but *tofdiŋ (/*tofⁿdiŋ/) → *tomdiŋ (since otherwise we should expect **tobdiŋ; however, note WM tepedingi).
  • Could support certain old loans such as kambing*kabi(n/ŋ) and tanduk*taduk. But, we see the same simplification behavior in *gutiŋ and Tobelo rate (from rantai). If nasalization was spontaneous in these Malay terms (like empat) and the NH forms are loaned from non-nasalized donors, then only do these loans support prenasalization.
  • Areally appears to be well-supported.
  • Evidence against:

Glottal Stop Insertion Rule

edit

Kotynski's glottal insertion rule: "Insert glottal stop before vowel-initial roots where that vowel is stressed."
He argues that it applies to PNH (what I'm calling PNNH - Proto Nuclear North Halmaheran, since West Makian needs better data). I propose that Kotynski's glottal insertion rule apply only to Proto-Northeast North Halmaheran (PNeNH). Specifically, PTT and PSahuic appear to have preserved a distinction between plain vowel initials and glottal stop initials, suggesting that /*ʔ/ was at least partly phonemic.

I tentatively propose a reconstruction *ca.'i.ʔit ("to hurry, quicken, hasten") with descendants including Tabaru taitaiti, Sahu cai'iti, and Ternate caicai. It appears as though the sequence *iʔi was reduced to *i in both PNeNH and PTT, but not in PSahuic. Comparing with *ti.ʔi.kit ("to cough"), with reflexes Galela tiiki, Tabaru ti'ikiti, Modole tii'iti, and Sahu ti'i'iti, the difference seems to be which syllable carries the stress. A stressed glottal stop may be preserved, whereas an unstressed one in a V1.ʔV1 sequence may not be.

Palatalization hypothesis

edit

The proto-consonant pairs p1, p2; t, c; d, j; n, ɲ; and l, L could all represent plain vs. palatalized consonants. In particular, it could be:

  • p2 = /p/; p1 = /pʲ/
  • t = /t/; c = /tʲ/
  • d = /d/; j = /dʲ/
  • n = /n/; ɲ = /nʲ/
  • L = /l/; l = /lʲ/

It's unclear if PNNH *b and *m had plain and palatalized realizations. It's also possible that this could extend somehow to the proto-consonants *S (/sʲ/?) and *ḋ (/gʲ/?), but more research is necessary. It also may shed light on the (tentative) relationship between PNNH and Tidore y.

If this is the case, then it was likely not triggered by back vowels, since Ternate, Tidore, and Sahu all maintain distinctions between sequences such as nyi and ni, ci and ti, etc.

Stressed Vowel Lowering Hypothesis

edit

All branches (Sahuic more than others) of Nuclear NH demonstrate considerable vowel assimilation, and primarily this appears to be the stressed vowel assimilating to the following vowel. What might facilitate this is lowering of the primary (and possibly secondary) stressed vowel in a word. Particularly, I posit that all branches of Nuclear NH experienced something resembling the following lowerings:

  • /'o/ → ['ɔ]
  • /'u/ → ['ʊ]
  • /'e/ → ['ɛ]

It is possible that /i/ lowered to /ɪ/, but I currently lack evidence of /i/ assimilation. In fact, almost all (all but *'i.gon) reconstructions with primary stress on /i/ have no other vowels (they're all /i/), which is extremely suspicious.

  • Actually, Van der Roest (his entries are more phonetic than phonemic) writes Tobelo (Boeng) hedete as the reflex of PNNH *'si.det, suggesting exactly that.

These lowerings may be indicated in Baarda's and others' vowel diacritics, but I have not figured out their system.

Additionally, there is evidence that the vowel directly preceding a stressed vowel may assimilate to the stressed vowel:

  • PNNH *bo.'te.kon → PNeNH *be.'te.kon, Sahu beteolo
  • PNNH *gol.'ci.p1ir → PNeNH *gi.'ci.p1ir, Waioli giciwidi
  • PNNH *mo.'na.ram → PNeNH *ma.'na.ram
  • PNNH *p1o.'ḋe.ka → PNeNH *p1e.'ḋe.ka
  • PNNH *p2o.'Li.kur → PNeNH *p2i.'li.kur

In many other cases, the preceding vowel is reconstructed to already be the same as the stressed vowel (*be.'Ze.Zoŋ, *'bo'ʔo.car, *p2e.'re.ki, *ti.'ʔi.kit, etc.), and so potential historical dissimilarities are currently undetectable. This may indicate that, if the stressed vowel lowering did in fact occur, it also occurred on the preceding vowel.

Could this also just be lowering of the first vowel? Uncertain.